Who doesn't love digging in to a slice of pie at the end of a meal, celebrating a holiday, or simply for no other reason than to treat yourself to something sweet? It's also a truly versatile dish. Savory or sweet, fruity or creamy, tart or a chocolate lover's dream — there's a perfect slice for everyone.

According to a list compiled by Yelp, the Ohio eatery serving up the "best pie" in the state is Just Pies in Westerville. The site notes that this beloved family-owned spot has dozens of sweet and savory options to choose from, with standouts like the Buckeye Pie and Peach Riot Pie. Just Pies is located at 736 Northfield Road #1.

Here's what Yelp had to say about determining which eateries serve the best pie in the U.S.:

"This is an all-time list of the top pie spots in the U.S. according to Yelp Elites. We identified businesses in the cafe and bakery categories with pie keywords, then ranked those spots based on the volume and ratings of reviews given by Yelp Elite Squad members for each business. If a spot with more than one location was featured, the location with the higher rating was featured. All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of February 17, 2025. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of February 17, 2025."

Check out the full list at yelp.com to read up on more of the best pie spots in the country. You can also see our previous coverage of the Ohio eatery named the "best cult-favorite restaurant" in the entire state.

Sitemap